My Perfect Pesto

A handful of times a week, someone will ask me, “Oh, you’re a food blogger! What are your favorite restaurants around here?” It’s been happening for a while now, so I’ve developed a standard, foolproof answer. It goes something like this: “Errrr, ummm, we don’t really — because I cook kind of a lot, and — if you like, well, there’s a totally decent sushi place, but — and this one time we went to that Italian joint with the lodge-y vibe and paid $23 for a glass of wine, so….” With any luck, by that point the frightened questioner will have backed away in small, studiously calm steps and joined a different conversation. This answer is foolproof in the sense that it provides proof of my foolishness as a food enthusiast and a human being.

Well. I may be an idiot, but I am an idiot with a scapegoat. And since my scapegoat is made of pulverized herbs (including scapes, in case you need a little closure in your life), the buck stops right there in the large mortar and pestle or bowl of a food processor fitted with the blade attachement.

The thing is, just like many of you, I’ve paid enough effortlessly obsessive attention to food and cooking in my lifetime that I know what I like, and I know how to cook it just the way I like it. I don’t mean that in a boastful way, believe me. If anything, it’s a big ol’ geek stamp on my dance card. It’s just that when I wake up dreaming of pesto, it’s not a half-assed, out-of-tune restaurant pesto on too much pasta that stirs me from slumber. It’s the pesto I’ve stayed at home on Friday nights tinkering with for years until it caresses each and every taste bud into a gentle state of euphoria. (At least I was getting some action, such as it was, on those lonely nights, right?)  At any rate, the food we eat at home is generally a lot tastier and a lot less expensive than what we’d get at a run-of-the-mill restaurant where we live. So when we go out — which we do, I swear — it’s rarely to be divinely inspired by the quality of the food. It’s for friends, or for date night, or for convenient Cal-Mex tacos, or for my desperate, long-running addiction to decent sushi. (You can tell it’s a true addiction, too, because sushi hasn’t been chic for a decade.)

While I clearly can’t offer you a valid restaurant recommendation, what I can offer is My Perfect Pesto. In the spirit of My Perfect Oatmeal and My Perfect Guacamole, this is the pesto recipe that would be my Platonic Ideal of a pesto recipe if Platonic Ideal meant what I always want to think it means, even though I attended a fancy four-year college.

This is good old basil pesto, but with a few meaningful tweaks that really bring it to life. For one thing, it’s heavy on the nuts, and I use walnuts instead of pine nuts for two reasons. Most of all, I simply prefer the mellow nuttiness of walnuts in pesto over the assertive presence of pine nuts. Also, though, buying pine nuts these days is a real bitch and a half. Spend $11 per quarter pound for the real thing, or settle for blandness up front with a lingering aftertaste of metal from the cheap imitation? Thanks, but no.

Second, while regular garlic is a perfectly adequate choice, I really prefer the gentle bite and additional bulk of scapes in my pesto these days. If you can get your hands on some scapes, I’d recommend using them. Third, I always prefer to brighten up my pesto with a little lemon juice. And fourth, technically, we are all supposed to be using a mortar and pestle or mezzaluna instead of a food processor to make our pesto. But at the moment, to be honest, I’d gladly take a free half hour and a slightly more homogenized sauce instead of an intact sense of food snobbery and a few extra specks of hand-mashed basil in my teeth.

Lord knows I don’t need basil in my teeth to embarrass myself at this point in my life. I’ve got my little speech about restaurant recommendations for that.

My Perfect Homemade Pesto
Serves 8
Write a review
Prep Time
15 min
Prep Time
15 min
  1. 1 cup shelled walnut pieces
  2. 6 garlic scapes, cut into 1/2-inch segments OR 2 large garlic cloves
  3. 6 gently packed cups fresh basil leaves
  4. 1 teaspoon fine sea salt
  5. 1/4 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper
  6. Juice of 1 lemon
  7. 1/2 cup extra-virgin olive oil
  8. 1/2 cup grated Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese
  1. Toast the walnuts in a small, dry pan over medium heat until they are fragrant and a little darker brown than they started out (3 to 5 minutes). Let cool slightly and pour into the bowl of a food processor fitted with the blade attachment.
  2. Add the garlic scapes or cloves, basil, salt, pepper, and lemon juice and process just until a thick paste forms. Stop to press any stray or stubborn basil leaves into the whirling action of the blade as necessary.
  3. With the motor running, pour the olive oil through the feed tube in a slow stream. Add the grated cheese to the bowl and process for a few seconds more to incorporate.
Umami Girl


Simple Coleslaw from Alice Waters | Umami Girl

Simple Coleslaw Recipe from Alice Waters

We spent the weekend visiting the kinds of friends who always introduce me to something new to love. It’s rarelyView full post »

Birthday Cake | Umami Girl

How to Decorate a Cake with Sheer Force of Will

Here’s a post on how to decorate a cake when what you’ve got is more will than skill. And you know it. AndView full post »

A Visit to Alicante, Spain | Umami Girl

A Visit to Alicante, Spain in Photos + Disclaimers

Disclaimer #1 I’ll just put it out there right away that this post about our visit to Alicante got lost at theView full post »

Potato Shiitake Garlic Scape Frittata | Umami Girl

Super-Savory Frittata with Potato, Shiitake and Garlic Scapes

At the risk of seasonal self-aggrandizement, I’m going to say that I feel like we got the pace of summer justView full post »

Baked Eggs with Tomato Sauce | Umami Girl

Flying Solo: Baked Eggs in Tomato Sauce and a Little Salad

Here’s a happy little number to launch your weekend: baked eggs in tomato sauce and a little salad. It’s aView full post »

With Wasabi Bloody Mary at Hillside Farmacy Austin TX | Umami Girl

A Visit to Austin

This spring we spent a few terrific days visiting with our growing population of friends in Austin. I hadn’tView full post »

Tell That to a Stiff G+T | Umami Girl

How to Make a Stiff Gin and Tonic

So here we are at the end of yet another too-complicated week for raising kids in America.View full post »

Sour Cherry Frozen Yogurt | Umami Girl

Sour Cherry Frozen Yogurt

Oh, did you think I was done posting sour cherry recipes? Just because we’ve talked about little else for weeks?View full post »

Sea Bright NJ Sunset | Umami Girl

Happy 4th of July Weekend

Our little neighborhood is really nailing the whole “America!” thing this weekend, so I thoughtView full post »

  • I have a fridge full of scape and a garden full of basil. To top it off, I’ve been on the search for the perfect pesto. Needless to say, this post is quite timely. :) Thanks for yet another wonderful recipe!ReplyCancel

  • I love the addition of lemon juice to the pestoReplyCancel

    • It seems so essential to me that I’m always surprised to remember it’s not part of the traditional recipe. Glad I’m not the only one!ReplyCancel

  • Leslie

    Can I still call it pesto if I don’t add the cheese? I don’t think soymage will quite be a good enough substitute.ReplyCancel

    • Definitely, and I think it will taste great without it, too. Some pestos don’t even have nuts in them, so as far as I’m concerned, you’re covered.ReplyCancel

  • Sounds like a familiar conversation. Lenny likes to say, we already eat at the best restaurant in town! I love pesto but do not make often enough. Whenever I have an overload of basil, I think, I should make pesto and put away in the freezer for a rainy day. I really should!!ReplyCancel

    • Denise, it is so worth it. I guess this may be a little less true where you live than where I do (for the next week, anyway!), but in the middle of February, there is nothing more gorgeous than a container of pesto defrosting on the countertop. xxReplyCancel

  • Yum! Love the garlic scapes in this, I totally need to try those in pesto! It looks so yummy :)ReplyCancel

  • I’m totally into it! I agree whole heartedly about food at home tasting better, although sometimes I’m tired and I’d like to say, oh I don’t know, whip out a batch of homemade pesto from the freezer ;)

    And I can empathize with those quiet Friday nights (although, for me, it’s because of a 2 year-old in bed, so we need to stay home – no family within 200 miles to babysit) Anyway, I feel ya on the homemade pesto and the blender. Fun post! :DReplyCancel

  • JanAnd

    “Big ole Geek stamp on my dance card.” Oh yeah, me too!ReplyCancel

  • Leah

    You are a genius – my husband has always been disappointed by my apathy towards pesto; it’s always too garlicky, or too oily, not basil-y enough, or missing “zing.” I made your recipe tonight, and it hit ALL the right notes. Consider me a pesto convert!ReplyCancel

  • We also pretty much never go out unless it is for friends or something i can’t make at home. Pesto is a fave and also freezes well. Your recipe sounds yummy!ReplyCancel

  • […] cup of your (or my) favorite basil pesto, […]ReplyCancel

Your email is never published or shared. Required fields are marked *