Best Lobster Roll Recipe: How to Make a Lobster Roll

Umami Girl is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn more here.

The best lobster roll recipe is simple and succulent, with a buttery roll and lightly dressed, sweet and savory lobster meat. Don't miss it.

Why we love this recipe

Of all my favorites in the world, lobster is right up there with family members. I should maybe be more embarrassed to say that than I am. If that's life in my 40s, I'll take it.

Instead, I'm leaning into the awkwardness with the best lobster roll recipe I know. (Technically, it's one of two equal favorites. This recipe is Maine-style, with chilled lobster salad — my other favorite is Connecticut-style, with warm, buttery lobster meat.)

Here's how to make a lobster roll at home, a.k.a. how to be an absolute boss who brings love and light to everyone in your life. This recipe has:

• Lots of tender, succulent lobster. You can make the rolls standard-sized and easy to pick up with ¼ pound of cooked meat per roll, or follow the supersize trend and use ½ pound of lobster — and a fork.
• Perfectly crisp, buttery, top-split buns. You can buy them or use my favorite recipe to make your own.
• A light, lemony dressing tossed right in with the meat, for the perfect balance of flavors in every bite.
• Pops of freshness and flavor from snipped chives or other soft spring herbs of your choice.

What you'll need

Here's a glance at the ingredients you'll need to make this recipe.

• For four standard-size lobster rolls, you'll need one pound of cooked lobster meat. There are so many ways to arrive at this point that I've dedicated a whole section to it below.
• Top-split buns (also called New England-style hot dog buns) have shellacked tops and naked sides that take well to buttering and skillet-toasting. Buy them or get next-level and make your own with our favorite recipe.
• You can use a good-quality supermarket mayo, an easy homemade version, or an extra-savory option: Kewpie mayo. This Japanese brand is creamier, tangier, and more umami-fied than its American counterpart.
• A generous amount of freshly squeezed lemon juice mixed right into the sauce makes all the difference in the world. If you've ever intuited that something's lacking from a lobster roll, I guarantee it was missing the perfect balance of acid and salt.
• Snipped chives provide a delicate, savory freshness and a little pop of color. You can use the green tops of scallions instead if that's what you've got, or mix things up with other soft spring herbs. I especially love mixing in a little bit of fresh tarragon (at about a 1:3 ratio with chives) when I have some on hand.
• Use a really good-quality butter if you can. Here and virtually everywhere, I start with a cultured, salted butter from grass-fed cows. This sounds fancy but doesn't have to be. Kerrygold, for example, is sold in most supermarkets at a reasonable price.

Sourcing lobster for rolls

Making lobster rolls is very quick if you start with pre-cooked meat, and that's great. I feel like the Barefoot Contessa would go that route, so in a sense it's unimpeachable. Traditionally, lobster rolls are made with claw and knuckle meat, which is succulent, tender, and flavorful (and leaves the tails for other preparations).

But if you ask me, by far the raddest way to make a lobster roll at home is to start with a live lobster and pick every morsel of meat from every part of the body. We're not just talking tails and claws, as you may have gathered from my tone.

Whatever your vibe, you've got options. You can:

• Start with live lobsters. Here's everything you need to know about how to find the secret nuggets of pure lobster gold that many people unwittingly throw away. It's basically a free MBA. On average, one pound of live lobster will yield about 3 ½ ounces of meat — but summer soft-shells will yield significantly less.
• Buy picked lobster meat at your local fish market. For the half the photos in this post, I went to one of my local markets and bought a gorgeous two-pound bag of flash-frozen claw and knuckle meat, then defrosted it on a rimmed half sheet pan at room temperature for an hour. (Contact with metal accelerates defrosting — it's science, but it's also magic.) Something weird about our economy is that I didn't pay more for this beautifully cooked, painstakingly shelled meat than I would have paid for its raw equivalent.
• Honestly, my favorite time to make lobster rolls is with leftovers in the days following a big feast. You wouldn't know it from the current state of affairs, but this sandwich originated as a delicious way to use up odd bits of lobster meat, and you should absolutely feel free to do the same.
• Or hey, go in the opposite direction and start with tails (or other parts) and cook them sous-vide.

How to make it

Here's an overview of what you'll do to make the best lobster roll recipe. You can see the steps in action in the video that accompanies this post, and get all the details in the recipe card below.

1. First you'll mix up the simple dressing.
2. Toss the dressing together with the lobster meat.
3. Butter and toast the buns.
4. Fill the warm, buttery buns generously with the lobster salad and serve right away. That's it!

Expert tips and FAQs

Make it a meal

Lean into summer by pairing the best lobster roll recipe with:

• A Hugo spritz
• Perfect potato salad
• Strawberry rhubarb crisp